Bettencourt's Bright Star Burns Out
Local legislators lament former majority leader's departure.
When former House Majority Leader D.J. Bettencourt first ran for state representative in Salem, locals could tell he was a young man with a bright future in politics.
Eight years later, Bettencourt has left the Legislature amidst scandal, leaving his local compatriots to look back with disappointment, albeit with some hope for his political future.
Bettencourt, 28, issued his immediate resignation from the House on Sunday. He originally announced his intent to resign effective June 6 to focus on his job as executive director of the New Hampshire Legal Rights Foundation and his family with his soon-to-be-wife Shannon Shutts, a staffer for House Speaker William O'Brien.
But Rep. Brandon Giuda, R-Chichester, came forward saying Bettencourt had faked internship reports to the University of New Hampshire School of Law. Giuda said Bettencourt claimed he'd spent a semester interning at Giuda's law office, which Giuda said wasn't true. Bettencourt admitted "misrepresenting" his reports and apologized for his actions.
Thus ended a career in the Legislature that began in 2004 when Bettencourt, a 20-year-old lifelong Salem resident, ran for a seat in the House, according to his extensive Patch profile biography. A year earlier, Bettencourt served as special aide to then-Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, now the presumptive Republican nominee for president.
Rep. Ron Belanger, R-Salem, recalled seeing him and his family members putting up election signs in 2004.
"I went over to (Bettencourt), shook his hand and wished him the best of luck," Belanger said Tuesday. "He was very cordial and polite."
Former House Speaker Donna Sytek of Salem said she saw an "ambitious" young man in Bettencourt that year.
"He's a gifted speaker and writer...he's terribly articulate," Sytek said. "This was a young man who could go places."
"He had a great deal of promise," said Rep. John Sytek, R-Salem, of Bettencourt.
Rep. Robert Elliott, R-Salem, said Bettencourt encouraged him to run for the Legislature in 2006. Elliott called Bettencourt's rise through the Concord ranks "meteoric."
"(Bettencourt) set the speed record," said John Sytek, adding that Bettencourt was part of a strong group of young Republicans he expected would take the reins in the Legislature.
Bettencourt made majority caucus whip in 2005 and served as a minority whip during 2009 and 2010. After the GOP landslide election of 2010, Donna Sytek said Bettencourt saw an opportunity to move up in the leadership.
For the first time, Republicans held an election to choose the majority leader. Sytek said the majority leader is typically selected by the speaker, a process Sytek prefers.
"You can't serve two masters," Sytek said.
Despite that, she believed Bettencourt served as an effective majority leader. At 27, Bettencourt was the youngest House majority leader in the country and the youngest ever in the state.
"Because of the skills he has, he was able to deliver the votes," she said. "It's too bad this scandal is going to distract from the accomplishments of this session."
Belanger said he believed Bettencourt was the best majority leader he'd worked with in his years in Concord.
"Some people were jealous of him because of his age and how smart he was," Belanger said. "He'd use words sometimes that I'd have to go look up. But he always handled himself professionally. He was a remarkable asset to the state of New Hampshire."
John Sytek said there was "no question" about how strong Bettencourt was in that position, although he often disagreed with the tenor of Bettencourt's writing.
"He remained accessible," Sytek said.
Bettencourt was the key sponsor on a bill that would allow for local municipalities to enact tax caps in 2010. He sponsored a constitutional amendment prohibiting an income tax. He served on the Ways & Means and Judiciary committees before becoming majority leader.
He was one of the leading voices throughout this legislative session about reducing the size of state government and attempting to balance the budget, which he told Patch last week was his best accomplishment in the House. He strongly backed the latest proposal to bring casino gambling to Rockingham Park, which failed.
Bettencourt made headlines in 2010 when he called Catholic Bishop John McCormack a "pedophile pimp" on his own Facebook page, for which Bettencourt later apologized to McCormack.
Later that year, Bettencourt was accused of falsifying mileage reimbursement forms, with opponents claiming he was living in Pembroke but was claiming mileage to Salem. A House counsel report cleared Bettencourt of any wrongdoing.
Days before announcing his resignation from the House, Bettencourt was appointed to the Salem Economic Development Action Committee by the Board of Selectmen, marking his first time holding local office.
His initial announcement Friday that he intended to resign June 6 at the end of the legislative session set in motion the series of events that led to his immediate resignation Sunday.
On Tuesday, the N.H. Legal Rights Foundation severed their ties with Bettencourt and he issued his resignation from the Salem EDAC to the Board of Selectmen.
O'Brien called Bettencourt's departure from the House "unexpected, shocking and very disappointing."
"I was shocked, and I feel a great sadness," Elliott said Tuesday.
"I'm very shocked, very disappointed and very upset," Belanger added.
Donna Sytek called the circumstance surrounding Bettencourt "a tragedy." But she would not rule out a political future for Bettencourt.
"He's not even 30 yet," she said. "He still has time to rehabilitate his image."
Bettencourt did not respond Tuesday for a request for an interview.
Rusty
7:48 am on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
I really think that it's time to let this whole thing rest. The kid has lost everything and I know that there are some who think he deserves it. I am sure that he and his family are suffering as much as you have all wanted him too. Some of the hateful remarks over the last few days are really over the top. To have a whole page on Patch devoted to him is unnecessary as well. The story is pretty much over. Time to find something else to take up your time.
salem activist
9:14 am on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
And I disagree..You can be sure if it was a Democrat the GOP would be milking this dryl. One big issue I also see is did House Speaker O'Brien know more than he's admitting. I think the their is more to this then he admitting. Time to expose him too!
L J
8:18 am on Thursday, May 31, 2012
I am sure that there is more info out there on him....For him to turn and resign immediately and then the Legal Rights Foundation axed him...why?
I am sure he DID falsify his travel records....problem is, 30 % of the reps prob do. That pandoras box they decided to keep closed.
AND the article talks about the great "sessions" he oversaw....EXCUSE ME? He made NH a laughing stock in the vein of Tennessee, Louisiana, and Arizona with some of the craziness (Magna Carta anyone?).....
GOOD RIDDENCE to a self serving, radical, extreme conserative monster in the making...
Bob Gibbs
8:37 am on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
I've been a supporter. I'm very disappointed that he apparently lied, drop the misrepresented stuff. He lied. I'm sad for Dj and Shannon, their new life is shattered before it starts.
But, when an elected official violates the people's trust there can't be too much focus on it. The problem is the attention is often bias and often not evenly handed out to all public officials who violate the people's trust.
Rusty
9:26 am on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
@salemactivist.. I am not going to have an online argument with a stranger but you are pitiful... I hope your children have turned out to be just as perfect as you apparantly are.... Again aren't you the one on Sunday who posted that you felt bad for Bettencourt's family?? ... not that bad I guess.
Don Duston
10:14 am on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Blah, blah, blah. Face it, the kid tried to take the easy way out and he got called on the carpet for his stupidity. He should never be allowed a JD degree from UNH either. Lawyers are supposed to become dishonest AFTER they pass the bar, DJ got a head start. Maybe now DJ will reinvent himself, ditch the child-like DJ name and use a grown-up name. Salem voters were stupid enough to vote Giordano in multiple times, so Bettencourt stands a good chance of fooling the Salem voters a few years down the road when the dust settles.
Bob Gibbs
12:21 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
@charliereid. Who's asking for a group hug? Careful about throwing rocks. Your Dem glass house has plenty of liars, frauds, and crooks in it. Everyone does. It's good when a bad seed gets exposed. It should keep all others on their toes.
Becky Keene
11:37 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
We all know everyone is wearing NASCAR/BANKSTER patches. Toss them all out when they are not representing the people!!!
Paul duffy
12:26 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Absolute Power corrupts absolutely
NH can do better!
Robert McAbee
12:34 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
I actually have no problem with the resume padding especially if he showed he could do the job. The problem I have are the corporate shills that are basically pulling up the ladder on the next generation by refusing to adequately pay for infrastructure, education and health care.
They do it in the name of their wealthy corporate owners. They go to colleges with low tuition costs then after they graduate have no problem supporting budgets that dramatically increase tuition.
kathleen carpenter
1:28 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Robert McAbee Bettencourt did not "pad" his resume. He was supposed to "work" for a number of weeks as an intern in Attorney Guida's law office . He spent one hour there one day and never went back. Instead of working his internship he made up as in FABRICATED pages and pages of court sessions he did not attend, meetings with clients that did not exist, legal work he supposedly did but did not do. In order to give this internship evaluation legitimacy one must assume he forged Attorney Guida's signature to this fictional piece. When I did an internship in a Doctor's office the Doctor had to fill out an evaluation of my work and sign it or I did not get my degree. One would assume UNH would have the same standard for a Law Degree as my College had for my Associates Degree. This is NOT A RESUME PADDING. This is an OVERT act of dishonesty. UNH is perfectly justified if they expelled him. This is not a youthful prank.....this shows a distinct personality trait of extreme lack of ethics and integrity and bold dishonesty. This man should never again be considered for any political office. How do you rehabilitate this?
L J
8:30 am on Thursday, May 31, 2012
Geeze Bob, that was not a "PAD" but a complete falsehood. WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU?
What this padding does is take AWAY the opportunity from someone who DID THE WORK, Put in the time, gave up other things to have the chance, and this BLOWHARD simply lied that he did these things.
YOU are horrible.
R McMillan
12:34 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
"He still has time to rehabilitate his image." Interesting, not just rehabilitate himself or his actions, just the image. Sounds like things are ripe for this guy to wait a few years, re-image himslef and do it all over again. When are we going to start holding people accountable again?
L J
8:30 am on Thursday, May 31, 2012
GREAT POINTS R McMillan.
He is symptamatic of the modern republican....Lie cheat and do not help those who are honest but poor....tough for them they won't lie and cheat their way to a better life.
He would be a good VP choice for the Vulture Capitalist Mitt Romney....
linda w
12:40 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
IT'S THE REPUBLICAN WAY. LIE, CHEAT, AND STEAL. THEY ALL TRUELY BELIEVE THEY ARE ABOVE THE LAW. BUT IT'S THE LAW THAT WILL BRING THEM DOWN. WATCH AND SEE. SCOTT WALKER, KARL ROVE, THE KOCH BROTHERS. IT'S ONLY A MATTER OF TIME. AND TIME WE ALL HAVE LIKE IT OR NOT
Patriot
7:26 am on Thursday, May 31, 2012
Oh come on Linda, the president allowed people to read his Bio for 16 years and never corrected it. Harvard graduate! He graduated from Harvard and never picked up on the supposedly lie? This is UNH!
L J
8:30 am on Thursday, May 31, 2012
Linda is right. "PATRIOT" is a foool.
Only in Salem
1:18 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
If Belanger likes DJ so much he can give him a job on his popcorn truck
Lisa Gale
2:06 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Bettencourt not only brought shame on himself and ridicule to the New Hampshire legislators, he brought a cloud over the University of New Hampshire School of Law. The only recourse, in my opinion, for UNH to show that they truly are dedicated to higher learning standards is to expel Bettencourt immediately. After that, the administration needs to investigate how it is possible for a student to intern for credits, send in fraudulent weekly reports of work completed, and determine that the criteria for the internship was completed without ever conducting a review with the law firm (in this case Mr. Guida).
I hope that this follows Mr. Bettencourt for the rest of his career, whatever that may be. I hope that he never is allowed to pass the bar in any state. A university education, once completed, is an accomplishment that one can truly be proud of. Mr. Bettencourt has tried to make a mockery of it.
Rob Presley
2:07 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
What? Another lying, cheating republican...I'm shocked I tell ya, shocked! NOT! The republican party is chalk full of guys like this, starting in the senate and going all the way down the line.
I'm sure he'll be heading up the koch brothers NH smear and lie campaign before the weeks out.
Patriot
7:26 am on Thursday, May 31, 2012
No Rob,, another politician! Look at the White House!!!!!!!
Underwater Couple
2:17 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Lyin and cheatin is spelled DEMOCRAT
LJoel Hackbart
9:15 pm on Friday, June 1, 2012
"Lying and cheating is spelled DEMOCRAT"?????????????????Remember'
you opened this door.
www.liberalslikechrist.org/gopcorruption.html
www.salem-news.com/articles/.../repub_scandals_10_17_07.php
www.wirenh.com/.../5239-bass-and-guinta-make-list-of-most-corrupt...
www.republicanoffenders.com/
dccc.org/index.php/corrupt
www.youtube.com/watch?v=kua0LlY3NAo
www.youtube.com/watch?v=YwJ9fgIqG0g
www.youtube.com/watch?v=zVWGdzSefIo
www.youtube.com/watch?v=0O7J5AjWGVA
David
4:17 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
So now he can go to work for Fox News?
Don Duston
6:15 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
@David, or go write for the Globe.
Patriot
7:26 am on Thursday, May 31, 2012
And compete with you at Msnbc
LJoel Hackbart
8:19 am on Tuesday, June 12, 2012
Or the Union leader, or the Eagle Tribune, or the Boston Herald, or TEANN.
Or any other right wing corporate propaganda outlet that Rupert Murdoch has got
his hand in.
Patriot
6:29 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
The most enjoyable post are written by democrats. You could hang a pound of meat on every syllable. The outrage over lying is so justified. The outrage over an elected official misrepresenting the record again beyond belief.
*
But ask them to force their fearless leader to tell the truth, or justify why he has said and had written that he was born in Kenya. NOOOOOO that is different!
*
Take your pound of flesh and enjoy the taste because it maybe awhile before you eat this good.
broberts
8:18 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Patriot, if you're talking about the book editor that mistakenly wrote that President Obama was born in Kenya, that story has been investigated thoroughly and has been noted as a mistake. Do your own investigation and don't rely on Trump for your talking points.
Patriot
7:26 am on Thursday, May 31, 2012
@broberts, "A Harvard Graduate" oh and do you think his bride would not have picked up on that little mistake? Where did she go to school? Please make hay while the sun shines!
No one could get past the humor created by the VP!
Rosemarie Rung
9:53 pm on Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Bettencourt is a narcissist...they have no concept of personal consequence, and when they are cornered, they try to cover it up (as he did when Rep. Guita called him out). He's no better than other narcissists caught in their own lies, and there are plenty of people in both parties that come to mind. One thing we have to applaud in all of this is the action of Rep. Guita. He was brave and honorable to bring the truth forward, despite the pressure he must have felt to protect his party from controversy.
Farmer
7:26 am on Thursday, May 31, 2012
So what is the big deal. He lied? Every politician I know lies everyday. If lying was such a bad thing how in the name of the IPU did Mitt Romney just get nominated for POTUS?
Patriot
7:26 am on Thursday, May 31, 2012
Depends on what the would is, is
How many times does a football player hit the dummy and get up and hit it again?
ostracario
7:26 am on Thursday, May 31, 2012
@Rosemarie Rung
He wasn't "brave and honorable" to admit that he'd lied. He got found out and came forward before anyone else could.
Rosemarie Rung
8:08 am on Thursday, May 31, 2012
Read my comment again, @ostracario...I was referring to Guita.
ostracario
7:26 am on Thursday, May 31, 2012
@Rosemarie Rung
Read another article on Patch about Bettencourt and, just as I thought, Guida found him out and called him on his massive fabrication. Forging of documents, forged signatures, the whole gamut:
Giuda was shocked by what he saw in the reports.
"There were 11 reports filed," Giuda said. "The detail in the reports is scary, and none of it is true. He details court hearings, he details clients, he details everything."
Rusty
7:59 am on Thursday, May 31, 2012
Guida wasn’t shocked-- he was delighted to get the chance to get rid of a political rival. In a few years we will see him running for a higher office and he will be reminding everyone how “truthful and self righteous” he was back in the spring of 2012
L J
9:41 am on Thursday, May 31, 2012
Write to the UNH School of Law and tell them to Vacate any degree awarded or to be awarded to this undeserving cad.
peter.davies@law.unh.edu
http://law.unh.edu/contact/
KevinK
12:59 pm on Saturday, June 2, 2012
I person who doesn't have their ego connected to the story could feel bad for everyone humiliated by Bettencourt's actions, including Bettencourt, WHILE feeling good that there is one less liar in government, AND more importantly, a line has been drawn that says to all politicians "you cn 't get away with THIS".
C'mon folks, get your egos out of politics. This isn't team sports. Everyone wants what they think is best for the nation, and everyone gets hurt when small powerful special interests control our politicians.
Can we all get behind this one thing, Left and Right? get the money out of the political system! PUBLICLY FUNDED ELECTIONS, NO MORE CONRIBUTIONS (BRIBES), no more lobbies.
If we all agree on this one thing it has a chance. And fixing that will fix or improve EVERYTHING wrong with our system.
Thanks, Bless..